As introduced in the video below, a motion to dismiss is where a defendant (or a plaintiff who is being sued in a counterclaim), moves the court to “throw out” all or part of the case against the defendant.

Motions to dismiss usually come in the early stages of a civil litigation.  Rule 12 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure provides that certain affirmative defenses in federal civil cases can be brought as motions to dismiss.  States have similar rules.

The idea behind a motion to dismiss is that there is something faulty in the plaintiff’s case that should prevent the case from continuing.

Examples of Motions to Dismiss

For example, let’s say a plaintiff sues a defendant in federal court for committing fraud.  And the complaint only describes the fraud in very general terms.   However, Rule 9 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure requires the plaintiff to allege the circumstances of the fraud with specificity.  Under these circumstances, the defendant could move the court to dismiss the claim for failure to state a claim because the complaint does not have the details required by Rule 9.

A few other grounds for a Court to grant a motion to dismiss is where the Court does not have personal jurisdiction over the defendant or the Court lacks subject matter jurisdiction, meaning it does not have the power to decide this type of case.

Courts often dismiss a claim or case without prejudice.  When a court dismisses a case without prejudice, the plaintiff will have an opportunity to fix whatever problem caused the court to dismiss the case.  In our example above, the court might allow the plaintiff an opportunity to add more facts to her fraud complaint to meet the requirements of Rule 9.



Get a Civ Pro Quiz Ebook!

101 Civ Pro Questions and Explanations

United States Law: An Introduction for International Students